Situation
Software vendor selection: how to choose between two proposals
Short answer. Send both vendors the same written list of what the integration must do and make each answer on it. Pick the proposal with one owner per record, one direction per flow and the simplest thing to run. Before you sign, ask both who runs it after delivery, how you leave and what is not in the price.
Why two proposals cannot be compared
Each vendor describes the work in its own words, with its own scope and its own price split. You end up comparing presentations, not solutions, and the best pitch wins.
The list both vendors answer
- Which system owns which data.
- Which direction each flow goes.
- What happens when a flow fails.
- Who runs the integration after delivery.
Three questions before you sign
- Who runs and fixes the integration after delivery?
- How do we get the flows and the data out if we leave you?
- What is not in the price?
What CDO Agent says
CDO Agent says: Give both vendors the same written list: which system owns which data, which direction each flow goes, what happens on an error and who runs the integration after delivery. Ask each to answer on that list, then choose the proposal that keeps one owner per record and one direction per flow, with the simplest thing to run. Before signing, ask both the same three questions: who runs and fixes the integration after delivery, how you get the flows and the data out if you leave them, and what is not in the price.
Questions
What is software vendor selection?
Choosing the vendor who builds or supplies software for you by comparing their answers to the same written requirements, not their presentations.
How many vendors should we ask?
For a new build, send the same request to three to five vendors with one deadline. When you already hold two proposals, the same written list for both is enough.
Should we pick the cheaper proposal?
Not on price alone. Compare what each includes, the running costs and who fixes the integration after delivery. An integration nobody runs costs more later.
How CDO Agent helps
Describe both proposals in your AI tool. CDO Agent recommends one, says why and lists the questions to put to each vendor. The decision stays yours. See pricing.